top of page

My Rating System

 

Every reader connects with a story differently. My ratings reflect my own reading experience: how invested I felt, how convincing the characters were, and whether the book delivered on what it promised.

​

I’m a mood reader, so what I’m looking for changes. Sometimes I want an elaborate fantasy world or an emotionally intense romance; sometimes I want something light and funny. A book doesn’t have to break my heart to earn five stars—it just has to do what it does exceptionally well.

​

★★★★★ — Loved it
A favourite. I was completely invested, and the characters or story stayed with me after finishing. It doesn’t have to be flawless, but whatever imperfections it has didn’t diminish how much I loved reading it.

​

★★★★☆ — Really enjoyed it
A book I would happily recommend. There were a few things that didn’t quite work for me, but the overall experience was thoroughly enjoyable.

​

★★★☆☆ — Liked it
An enjoyable read with some reservations. Perhaps I loved certain elements but struggled with others, or the story simply didn’t leave a lasting impression. Three stars is still a positive rating.

​

★★☆☆☆ — Not quite for me
There may have been things I appreciated, but I struggled to stay invested. The characters, pacing, writing, or plot didn’t come together for me.

​

★☆☆☆☆ — Didn’t enjoy it
A reading experience that largely didn’t work for me, with significant issues that affected my enjoyment.

What can affect my rating?

​

I’m all for literature pushing boundaries. I read dark romance, after all. But I believe sensitive subjects deserve care and consideration for the intended readership. How a story handles those themes matters to me, and a complete absence of consent between romantic partners is a firm personal boundary.

​

Character decisions matter, too. I don’t need characters to be perfect or agree with everything they do, but I need to understand their choices within the story.​

And misunderstandings that could be resolved with one short conversation? Those test my patience. I understand that stories need conflict, but there’s a difference between drama that moves the plot forward or develops the characters and drama that seems to exist purely to keep them apart for another hundred pages.

​

If the only obstacle is “I’m not good enough for him/her” *cue eye-roll* and there’s nothing in the story to make that fear convincing, I may put the book down. Give me a reason to believe in the conflict, even if it frustrates me.

​

DNF — Did not finish

I’m someone who hates leaving things unfinished, so putting down a book doesn’t always come easily. But if I’m no longer enjoying the experience, I give myself permission to move on.

If I discuss a book I haven’t finished, I’ll make that clear and explain why I stopped, without giving it a star rating.

​

What you’ll find on this blog

​

Confessions of a Reader primarily features books I enjoyed and want to recommend. That means the reviews here naturally lean towards higher ratings. I’ll still discuss weaknesses, frustrations, and anything I wish had been handled differently.

​

My reviews are honest, personal, and respectful. They’re an invitation to discover a story you might love—not a final verdict on what anyone else should enjoy.

  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • goodreads-512
  • email_icon

Copyright © 2026 Confessions of a Reader

Website created by Wix

Hosted by Hostinger | Privacy Policy

bottom of page
No fixes needed.