
My Rating System
Every reader connects with a story differently. My ratings reflect my own reading experience: how invested I felt, how convincing the characters were, and whether the book delivered on what it promised.
I’m a mood reader, so what I’m looking for changes. Sometimes I want an elaborate fantasy world or an emotionally intense romance; sometimes I want something light and funny. A book doesn’t have to break my heart to earn five stars—it just has to do what it does exceptionally well.
★★★★★ — Loved it
A favourite. I was completely invested, and the characters or story stayed with me after finishing. It doesn’t have to be flawless, but whatever imperfections it has didn’t diminish how much I loved reading it.
★★★★☆ — Really enjoyed it
A book I would happily recommend. There were a few things that didn’t quite work for me, but the overall experience was thoroughly enjoyable.
★★★☆☆ — Liked it
An enjoyable read with some reservations. Perhaps I loved certain elements but struggled with others, or the story simply didn’t leave a lasting impression. Three stars is still a positive rating.
★★☆☆☆ — Not quite for me
There may have been things I appreciated, but I struggled to stay invested. The characters, pacing, writing, or plot didn’t come together for me.
★☆☆☆☆ — Didn’t enjoy it
A reading experience that largely didn’t work for me, with significant issues that affected my enjoyment.
What can affect my rating?
I’m all for literature pushing boundaries. I read dark romance, after all. But I believe sensitive subjects deserve care and consideration for the intended readership. How a story handles those themes matters to me, and a complete absence of consent between romantic partners is a firm personal boundary.
Character decisions matter, too. I don’t need characters to be perfect or agree with everything they do, but I need to understand their choices within the story.
And misunderstandings that could be resolved with one short conversation? Those test my patience. I understand that stories need conflict, but there’s a difference between drama that moves the plot forward or develops the characters and drama that seems to exist purely to keep them apart for another hundred pages.
If the only obstacle is “I’m not good enough for him/her” *cue eye-roll* and there’s nothing in the story to make that fear convincing, I may put the book down. Give me a reason to believe in the conflict, even if it frustrates me.
DNF — Did not finish
I’m someone who hates leaving things unfinished, so putting down a book doesn’t always come easily. But if I’m no longer enjoying the experience, I give myself permission to move on.
If I discuss a book I haven’t finished, I’ll make that clear and explain why I stopped, without giving it a star rating.
What you’ll find on this blog
Confessions of a Reader primarily features books I enjoyed and want to recommend. That means the reviews here naturally lean towards higher ratings. I’ll still discuss weaknesses, frustrations, and anything I wish had been handled differently.
My reviews are honest, personal, and respectful. They’re an invitation to discover a story you might love—not a final verdict on what anyone else should enjoy.
